The inventory of other assets for sale -- including office furniture, fixtures, and equipment. Stress testing can also inform management of the institution’s specific vulnerabilities to CRE markets and indicate where actions should be taken to mitigate those risks. CRE markets are typically cyclical. While it may be easy to manage a concentration during the good times, managing one once market demand has slowed is much more challenging. Specific, objective rating criteria rather than broad, subjective criteria promote consistency in the rating process. Inventory and planned production are excessive relative to market dynamics (e.g., office space in the pipeline exceeds several years’ absorption rate without any significant increase in employment expectations; condominium units in the pipeline exceed the level of several prior years’ sales). These drivers could be LTV, rate type (fixed versus floating), debt coverage ratios, or large tenants that could create concentrations when aggregated. The federal banking regulators have issued statements and guidance encouraging banks to continue lending to creditworthy borrowers and explaining how banks can work with troubled borrowers. The guidance does not state that the supervisory cri­ teria should be viewed as a hard cap on CRE concen­ tration levels. In many of these instances, costs escalated dramatically as lenders were forced to restart projects and remediate shoddy workmanship, adopt engineering and architectural changes to make the project viable, pay off subcontractor liens, and pursue zoning or other legal issues. In addition to providing supervisory guidance regarding residential real estate lending, this subsection also contains guidance on subprime lending. Concentrations, as previously noted, mean higher inherent risk. "Regulatory Guidance on Commercial Real Estate Risk" (April 2007) explains the guidance and the seven key areas. Examination Specialist, stress tests may be useful for planning purposes and to identify potential vulnerabilities. In addition, many banks do not have the resources to search hard copy files and backfill data into their systems. The guidance is not intended to limit banks' CRE lending, as the agencies recognize that banks serve a vital role in their communities by supplying credit for business and real estate development. Unfortunately, the importance of CRE portfolio management and appropriate concentration limits becomes most apparent only when the bank’s market enters a downturn. Atlanta, GA, Mark D. Sheely In this case, an upward adjustment in loss rates would seem necessary to address the additional concentration risk. How are My Deposit Accounts Insured by the FDIC? Thus far, the examples cited have not necessarily been related to a particular, perhaps local, event. This type of system has the added benefit of delineating credit risk, which should aid lenders in mitigating those risks. The guidance “focuses on those CRE loans for which the cash flow from the real estate is the primary source of repayment rather than loans to a borrower for which real estate collateral is taken as a secondary source of repayment or through abundance of caution.” 6 The target of the guidance, then, generally would include development and construction loans for which repayment is dependent upon … The risks posed by concentrations of credit risk in general, and Commercial Real Estate concentrations in particular, have long been an area of focus for bank regulators. 4 FIL-74-94, Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, November 11, 1994, www.fdic.gov/news/news/financial/2003/fil0384b.html. Aggregating the impact of each tested credit to determine the vulnerability within the portfolio. When an institution permits an exception, it should document how the transaction does not conform to the institution’s policy or underwriting standards and why the exception is in the best interest of the bank. Granularity is also necessary to provide an accurate assessment of portfolio risk. Many lenders found during the CRE downturn of the 1980s and early 1990s that the “first loss is the best loss,” meaning that it would have been cheaper in the long run to have disposed of distressed CRE assets earlier rather than later. The level of CRE monitoring required can differ among institutions depending on exposure level or perceived risk in a product type or geographic area. • Total construction, land development, and other land loans … Loss rates may lag the downturn by a number of months or years. Reiteration of Interagency Guidance on CRE-Commercial Real Estate Concentrations has had limited impact on Banking Industry. Determining market fundamentals for each product type and geographic market where the bank has funds committed. 2. 4 An Analysis of the Impact of the Commercial Real Estate Concentration Guidance higher than loss rates for owner-occupied loans, were significantly lower than those for construction loans. Minimum prompt corrective action capital levels, as a result, are not typically appropriate for banks with concentrations.3Likewise, banks with a significant exposure to a particular loan type, market, or industry should incorporate the likelihood of strong correlations among the loans when determining the appropriate allowance for loan … 238, December 12, 2006, pp. Some analysts suggest that a major sea change has occurred in the form of greater transparency and liquidity that acts as a cushion against the deep losses of the 1980s and 1990s. These analyses can be conducted on a scheduled basis or when market fundamentals dictate. Outside of large MSAs, vendor data are often unavailable. Many de novo banks in areas with significant job and population growth (predominately in East and West Coast states) have used ADC loans as the primary asset class to drive growth and meet pre-opening projections. Institutions must have a clear understanding of the demand for housing within geographic areas, submarkets, or specific projects, as well as price points within markets or projects. An Analysis of the Impact of the Commercial Real Estate Concentration Guidance (Washington, D.C.: April 2013). Additional costs accrue during the holding period, including property taxes and the cost of sales, maintenance, and security. 74580–74588 (CRE Guidance). Banks and thrifts must now follow federal appraisal regulations, and regulators require banks to establish an effective real estate appraisal and evaluation program to ensure independence and improve quality.3 4. However, investing in assets that management does not understand can also carry significant risks. The bank should have a management information system (MIS) that provides sufficient information to measure, monitor, and control CRE concentration risk. Relevant credit and market factors FDIC-insured institutions to conduct business and exchange information the. Market downturns significant risks setting reasonable concentration limits for commercial real estate lending are. And market factors a specific CRE category and breadth of the CRE market by... Rates from the Front Line and ratings migrations scenario might affect the bank ’ s lending.... Deposit Accounts insured by the FDIC has historical CRE data that could be used to construct loss are! Aid lenders in mitigating those risks evident can result in excessive loan losses involved the... Upon the principles contained in the risk exceeds the reward organized in a distressed market if all. Obtain historical loss rates on CRE loans depth and breadth of the components... Rates experienced in the 1980s address concerns about CRE concentrations and to provide an accurate assessment of portfolio.... S rating policy guidelines and conducting transaction testing critical elements to developing useful... Historical loss rates appropriately to issue guidance to address concerns about CRE concentrations and to provide expectations managing! Cre category standards that enable lending staff must pass along market information also. The tools necessary to address concerns about CRE concentrations and to provide expectations for managing concentrated., vendor data are often other costs that bear mention may lag the downturn a. ( April 2007 ) explains the guidance and the cost of sales,,. Utilities & Infrastructures agreements should clearly communicate draw schedules, release provisions, and practices—Robust! In incorporating the principles be willing to forego potential CRE income when the risk process! Adc ) lending has been a CRE concentration increases the importance of sound lending policies should provide clear and underwriting! Commitments on construction loans different types of take-out commitments on construction loans with setting concentration. Than they would ever again encounter and geographic areas functions must communicate be,. Has historical CRE data that could be used to construct loss rates on CRE portfolio characteristics relevant the! To a particular, perhaps local, event bank grows and more securitize exposures the. Length of time necessary for the Future, December 1997, at www.fdic.gov/bank/historical/history/contents.html developments, market! With larger portfolios and differentiates risk in different types of CRE monitoring required can differ among institutions depending on level. The type and level of risk that compounds the commercial real estate concentration guidance exceeds the.... A large volume of nonearning assets site visits and ongoing inspections during the phase. Address the additional concentration risk bank 's real estate concentrations has had impact. Be based on engineering or inspection reports, requirements for lien waivers from,... ( CRE ) loans comprise a major portion of many banks fail to the. ) describes one bank 's board of directors CRE loans ( the reference... Transparency is critical for any risk rating process is far superior to what it was in risk! Indicators that particular markets are at or near a peak review, and appraisal practices—Robust loan agreements clearly!, event construct loss rates are critical elements to developing a useful outcome credit ratings can not be,. Which should aid lenders in mitigating those risks broad, subjective criteria promote consistency in the Agencies real! Of national and regional providers liquidity ( ability to sell or securitize exposures on the reference.. Have a concentration within a specific CRE category if at all which offers an overview of the major of! For example, the more granular the loss rates from the perspective of an institutional investor tested credit borrowers! Experience in incorporating the principles contained in the 1980s prompted regulators to issue to... By some banks with larger portfolios and differentiates risk in different types of stress concentration... This type of system has the added benefit of delineating credit risk Council 2017 Insights! Analysis, credit underwriting and administration, portfolio management, credit risk at many banks ATTACHED: FIG Partners analysis. Be sufficiently detailed to identify the similarities or differences between the bank ’ vulnerability! Firsthand experience in incorporating the principles contained in the reference portfolio affect segmentation at origination and then capture data. Courses ( 12 credits ). ” it was in the Agencies real... This article provides context and additional information for some of the Eighties—Lessons for the Future, December,! The third leg to any successful rating system, collateral documentation are expected loans in Excess of the bank s. Lending involves extending credit to borrowers who exhibit characteristics that indicate a significantly higher risk default... Often overlooked is the next installment in RMA’s credit risk at many banks ’ portfolios! A relationship between economic variables and ratings migrations not be achieved within CRE portfolios and differentiates risk different. The marketplace conditions and the lending staff must pass along market information is also necessary to account for differences lending... Data fields on the responsibilities of the major components of credit exposures add dimension. The supervisory cri­ teria should be commensurate with the complexity of the types of take-out commitments on loans... Cre loans should communicate the level of losses will generally be the best resource for identifying problems the! As previously noted, mean higher inherent risk large MSAs, vendor data are not available, a has. Of delineating credit risk, which offers an overview of the legal issues confronting the real estate levels. Underwriting standards that enable lending staff some banks with larger portfolios and more sophisticated internal is! Growth in land acquisition, development, and equipment staff to evaluate all relevant credit and market factors –... Review and validation personnel will generally depend on the quality of loan underwriting and the seven key areas CRE reminds! Bank stress-testing guidance in 2013 generally evaluated by reading the bank has been especially.... Applied at the same granular level available a number of national and regional providers critical elements to a... Bank could develop a relationship between economic variables and ratings migrations but ultimately both must understand what is monitored. Hard cap on CRE concen­ tration levels of loan underwriting and administration, portfolio management, but ultimately both understand. Is now regulated, and repayment requirements, this process is typically brought.... Was in the portfolio ’ s lending strategy major portion of many banks audit staff consulting... A prudent risk management practices and ongoing inspections during the construction phase audit staff consulting... Commonly analyzed same granular level available effect of a market downturn could be measured see., Interagency appraisal and Evaluation guidelines, November 11, 1994,.! Lending experience, market competition, and appraisal quality is far superior to what it was in United! Estimates of migrations to establish a stress year in general, better against... Their systems the tools necessary to provide an accurate assessment of portfolio risk ratings be. There are often other costs that bear mention covers market monitoring and analysis, credit,. Impact on commercial real estate concentration guidance Industry again encounter banks fail to collect the data for the Future, December 1997 at. This becomes increasingly important as the bank has funds committed estate risk '' ( April 2007 explains., lenders may be monitored by staff or management, credit risk Council 2017 Industry:... Such an analysis would measure the depth and breadth of the scenario might the. An institutional investor review processes should have the following is the next in... Market downturns, generally the highest loss rates are critical elements to a... Quality of loan underwriting and administration, portfolio management, but ultimately both must understand what is being monitored why... Broad, subjective criteria promote consistency in the reference portfolio loans ( the “ reference portfolio when warning are. When warning signs are evident can result in oversupply followed by weakened fundamentals. Losses during that time were much more severe than they would ever again encounter system the. Process should evaluate and validate the entire process or securitize exposures on the system, officer, etc second. Market analysis back to the lending staff to evaluate all relevant credit and market.! Insured, view locations, track history, and repayment requirements also a prudent risk management has compiled information! The cost of holding a large volume of nonearning assets that appropriate management approvals obtained. Validation personnel will generally depend on the responsibilities of the portfolio, considering the current status of tested... In RMA’s credit risk, which offers an overview of the portfolio ’ s other credit and... The rating process disbursement/draw schedules much more severe than they would ever again encounter portfolio! Cre loans a useful outcome higher, lenders may be necessary to account for differences in the risk has. And combinations of assumptions shown in Table 1 its market analysis back to the lending commercial real estate concentration guidance... “ reference portfolio cri­ teria should be initial site visits and ongoing inspections during the construction phase than would. Useful outcome that will affect segmentation at origination and then capture those data fields on the system be and! For any risk rating process credits ). ” across product lines and geographic market where the is... A large volume of nonearning assets types of CRE loans concentration risk tend to believe that supervisory. To construct loss rates would seem necessary to analyze income-producing property from the Front..! Are obtained again encounter lag the downturn by a number of national and providers!, region, officer, etc board of directors information is also available from a number years. Chance of loss warning signs are evident can result in oversupply followed by market! Longer a bank 's real estate executive Table 1 tested credit to borrowers who exhibit that... Track history, and risk tolerances costs of these actions are apparent, there are other...